• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
This Mess is Ours logo
  • Recipes
    • All Recipes
    • The Blog
  • Dog Life
    • Dog House Home
    • Dog Food Recipes
  • Shop
    • Snack + Supplies
      • Gluten Free (Snacks + More)
      • Kitchen Essentials
      • Lunchbox Gear
      • Pantry Staples
      • Cookbook Faves
  • About
    • My Story
    • Web Stories
    • As Seen On ATL+CO
    • PORTFOLIO
menu icon
go to homepage
search icon
Homepage link
  • Browse Recipes
  • Dogs
  • Shop
  • About
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
  • ×
    Home » Recipes » Recipes

    Brown Butter Sugar Plum Snack Cake + A Brown Butter How-To

    Tweet
    Pin
    Share
    0 Shares
    Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe

    Let’s talk about what happens when a stick of butter meets a pan and a cook who has the patience to stand at the stove for eight minutes. Part recipe, part brown butter how-to, and part postcard from Paso Robles, this post is fully stacked. By the end, you’ll know how to make brown butter without torching it, and you’ll have a Brown Butter Sugar Plum Snack Cake on your counter that tastes like all of the best flavors of the holiday season wrapped up into one bite.

    This spiced cake has the ultimate tender crumb, built on the bones of the best snack cake I have ever created. Am I biased? Absolutely. Am I also right? Also yes.

    This sugar plum-inspired version calls for browned butter for a rich, nutty backbone and soaked, then mashed, California prunes for moisture and deep, jammy sweetness. On top sits a mix of chopped fruit, nuts, cinnamon, and pearl sugar that bakes into something close to candy. Soft cake underneath. Crackly sugar on top. Chewy dried fruit and toasty nuts in every single bite.

    Sponsorship disclosure: This post was created in partnership with California Prunes. All opinions, obsessions, and Cherry Bombe moments are entirely my own.

    What Is a Sugar Plum, Anyway?

    Is a sugar plum fruit? Sort of, and also not at all. A sugar plum is an old-fashioned holiday candy. The Nutcracker made it famous, yet most of us have never actually eaten one. The earliest versions date back to the 1600s, when people coated seeds or nuts in layer after layer of hard sugar through a slow process called panning. They came out round and a little lumpy, roughly the size and shape of a plum. Hence the name.

    Traditional sugar plums recipe

    Traditional Sugar Plums

    The G-Free Foodie taught me everything I know about real-deal sugar plum candy: dried fruit, toasted nuts, and warm spices rolled in crunchy sugar. No baking required.

    Prunes sit at the heart of sugar plums, and my friend K.C., the G-Free Foodie, will happily argue with anyone who says otherwise. Her traditional sugar plum recipe is my gold standard. It’s also the blueprint for this cake: tender inside, crunchy and sugary outside, and loaded with holiday spice.

    Images for this section of the blog post provided by California Prunes & CA GROWN

    A Weekend in Paso Robles With California Prunes and Cherry Bombe Magazine

    Every recipe has an origin story, and this one starts in Paso Robles. In late September, I joined California Prunes at Cherry Bombe Magazine’s Farmers & Makers event, a weekend of tastings, dinners, and conversations honoring the International Year of the Woman Farmer. An immersive weekend spent celebrating the women behind what we eat and drink. Count me in.

    If you’ve never been to Paso, picture wine country merged with farmland and an incredible community that feels more like somewhere you'd want to live than a place you'd just pass through. Mornings start at the farmers market. Afternoons drift from one tasting room to the next. Nobody rushes, and the locals are so nice that you quickly start to feel like you truly belong there. Don't even get me started on the incredible food scene that is happening in and around Paso. I can assure you that your taste buds will never tire of the options there.

    The Best Things To Do When Visiting Paso Robles

    The Best Things To Do When Visiting Paso Robles

    I have written about my love of visiting the Paso region before on This Mess is Ours. From some of my favorite wineries to visit to the lights of Sensorio, there is always an abundance of things to do and taste in and around Paso.

    Click here to read the full article.

    Friday night kicked off with a welcome party at the Austin Hope and Treana Tasting Cellar. They poured so many incredible wines, served bite after bite of delicious food, and brought together friends both old and new. It was one of those rare nights that just feels like pure magic from start to finish.

    Saturday brought morning yoga and lunch at J. Lohr Vineyards & Wines, about ten minutes outside of downtown Paso. Co-owner and chief brand officer Cynthia Lohr welcomed us to a delicious wine pairing lunch at the edge of the vineyard where J. Lohr’s lineup of white wines met spectacular, season-inspired bites and an inspiring talk from Secretary Karen Ross.

    Late Saturday afternoon belonged to the Cherry Bombe X CA GROWN Farmers & Makers Market at the Paso Robles Inn. We strolled, we snacked, we met some really innovative and inspiring women in food and agriculture.

    The courtyard of the Inn was transformed into a beautiful, bustling market for the day. Even the air buzzed with the incredible energy of female-led farms, wineries, and food businesses sharing their passion for what they do. Between sampling sessions, we enjoyed thought-provoking panels in the 1889 House ballroom.

    Saturday night California Prunes hosted She’s My Cherry Pie: After Dark at EMRE inside The Ava Hotel. Chef Sarah Thompson of Casa Playa at Wynn Las Vegas cooked an insanely delicious custom tasting menu.

    Then for dessert, Jessie Sheehan, host of the Cherry Bombe baking podcast She’s My Cherry Pie, moderated a panel of pastry chefs in a discussion before turning us loose on an incredible dessert bar stacked with signature bites from the panelists.

    One treat during the trip stopped me cold: Sugar Plum Shortbread cookies from Brown Butter Cookie Company, made with California prunes just for the evening. Brown butter. Sugar plums. Prunes. Hubba. hubba!

    You can probably guess by now that I was scribbling my first thoughts of creating this snack cake recipe in my notes app on the flight back home.

    Spending a weekend celebrating women in agriculture made one thing very clear. Good ingredients start with people who care, and California prunes are proof. They’re grown and dried right here in California, naturally sweet, and rich enough that this cake tastes like dessert without a mountain of sugar. That’s why they earn the starring role.

    Why You Must Make This Sugar Plum Snack Cake

    Snack cakes are easy-to-make counter cakes. You keep them out, cut a sliver with your morning coffee, and come back for another sliver whenever your heart desires. No layers, no frosting drama, no occasion required, really. And a cake that gets better the longer it sits.

    Each ingredient has a job in building the flavor. The soaked, mashed California prunes keep the crumb moist for days. Brown butter adds a nutty flavor that plain melted butter simply can’t match. Orange zest and fresh juice brighten everything, while the warming flavors of ginger and cinnamon keep it all cozy.

    Finally, the cinnamon-spiced fruit-and-nut topping gives you that nostalgic sugar plum crunch on top of every slice. This recipe swaps easily to gluten-free cup-for-cup flour, so everybody at the table gets a piece.

    Brown Butter How-To: Step by Step

    Brown butter is regular butter cooked past the melted stage until the milk solids toast and the whole pan turns golden brown. One ingredient. One pan. The payoff makes baked goods, sweet and savory dishes, and everyday baking recipes taste like a pro was involved. Here’s how to make brown butter the right way.

    1. Grab a light-colored pan

    A light colored saucepan or skillet lets you see the color change as it happens. In a dark pan, golden brown and burnt butter look exactly alike until your nose breaks the news.

    2. Cut the butter

    Slice it into tablespoon-sized pieces. Smaller pieces melt at the same rate, so the butter browns evenly instead of scorching in one spot while another lump stays solid.

    3. Use medium heat and stay put

    Set the pan over medium heat. As the butter melts, it will start to foam and sizzle around the edges. That’s the water cooking off. Stir the butter the whole time, scraping the bottom of the pan so everything can cook evenly.

    4. Watch for brown specks

    After a few minutes, the foam settles, and tiny brown specks appear. Those are the milk solids, which sink to the bottom of the pan and start to toast. The butter shifts from pale yellow to golden, then to warm amber. Meanwhile, a nutty aroma fills the kitchen, a lot like toffee and toasted hazelnuts.

    5. Stop the cooking process

    The second it smells nutty and starts to turn golden brown to amber, pour it into a heatproof bowl, brown bits and all. Those toasted milk solids carry most of the flavor, so scrape out every last one. If you leave the butter in the hot pan, it keeps cooking, and will burn the toasted solids turning the flavor verry bitter.

    Dress It Up Like a Sugarplum

    The cake is great as-is, plain, no icing drizzle or crispy meringues. Still, if you want it to look like it belongs on the Sugar Plum Fairy’s dessert table, here’s the move. Press a few meringue pieces into the top while the cake is still warm so they stick. Once it cools to room temperature, drizzle on a quick powdered sugar icing, then shower it with sanding sugar and a little edible purple glitter. Is glitter necessary? No. Is it fun? Very.

    More Sugar Plum Recipes Worth Making This Season

    Once sugar plum flavors get into your head, you won't be able to start thinking about them. Here are a few more recipes to keep the party going.

    Sugar Plum Shortbread Cookies

    Buttery shortbread folded with finely diced California prunes, dates, cranberries, and almonds. My favorite holiday cookie, hands down.

    Sugar Plum Shortbread Cookie recipe

    Warm Sugar Plum Cocktail

    This cocktail from G-Free Foodie is made with spiced rum, orange and prune juices, and warm spices, making for a perfect holiday cocktail.

    Print

    Brown Butter Sugar Plum Snack Cake

    Print Recipe
    Pin Recipe

    5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

    No reviews

    Part snack cake, part sugar plum, and every reason to keep a loaf on the counter this season. Nutty brown butter and soaked, then mashed, California prunes give this spiced cake a moist, tender crumb. On top, a crackly mix of chopped prunes, dates, nuts, cinnamon, and pearl sugar bakes up like the holiday candy that inspired it. It’s out of the oven in about 30 minutes and swaps easily to gluten-free.

    • Author: This Mess is Ours
    • Prep Time: 20 min
    • Cook Time: 30 min
    • Total Time: 50 minutes
    • Yield: 8 slices 1x
    • Category: Dessert
    • Method: Baking
    • Cuisine: American

    Ingredients

    Scale
    • 6 tablespoons unsalted butter, sliced into tablespoon-sized pieces

    For the topping

    • 3 California prunes, diced fine
    • 2 dates, sliced thin
    • 1 tablespoon dried cranberries, minced
    • 1 tablespoon slivered almonds
    • 1 tablespoon raw pistachios, coarsely chopped
    • ¼ teaspoon ground cinnamon
    • 1 tablespoon pearl sugar

    For the snack cake

    • ¼ cup diced California prunes, about 7
    • 1 cup boiling water
    • ½ cup packed dark brown sugar
    • 2 egg yolks
    • 1 navel orange, zested and juiced (about ⅓ cup juice)
    • 1 teaspoon vanilla bean paste or vanilla extract
    • 1 cup all-purpose flour (spooned and leveled, not scooped) or gluten-free cup-for-cup flour
    • ½ teaspoon ground ginger
    • ½ teaspoon ground cinnamon
    • ¼ teaspoon coarse kosher salt
    • ½ teaspoon baking powder

    Optional sugarplum garnishes

    • Powdered sugar icing (recipe in notes)
    • 3 to 4 small meringue cookies or large meringue pieces
    • Sanding sugar
    • Edible purple glitter

    Instructions

    Brown the butter

    1. Before you start: brown butter moves fast, so stay put at the stove. Set a heatproof bowl right next to the burner so it’s ready for step 3.
    2. Add the butter to a light-colored pan over medium heat. A light pan lets you actually see the color change, and medium heat keeps everything cooking evenly, which is the whole game here. Stir constantly. Once it melts, the butter will start to foam and sizzle around the edges. Keep stirring. After 5 to 8 minutes total (more butter means more time), it turns a deep golden brown. The foam settles down, the milk solids on the bottom go toasty brown, and your kitchen will smell rich, nutty, and seriously buttery.
    3. Pull the pan off the heat the second it gets there and pour the butter, browned bits and all, into your waiting bowl. Leave it in the hot pan and the leftover heat keeps cooking it. Brown butter turns into burnt butter in seconds. Allow the butter to cool while preparing the rest of the ingredients.
    4. While the butter is cooling, pour the boiling water over the ¼ cup diced prunes and soak for 15 minutes.
    5. Meanwhile, preheat the oven to 350°F. Line a 9-inch loaf pan with parchment, then lightly spray with cooking spray and set aside.
    6. After the prunes have soaked, reserve 1 tablespoon of the soaking liquid and drain the rest. Use a fork to mash the prunes and the reserved soaking liquid into a paste with no big chunks remaining.
    7. Next, make the topping. Combine the remaining 3 diced prunes, sliced dates, cranberries, almonds, pistachios, and cinnamon in a small bowl. Stir until the cinnamon has adhered to the fruit, then add the pearl sugar and stir to combine. Set aside.
    8. In a large mixing bowl, combine the mashed soaked prunes, brown butter, dark brown sugar, egg yolks, orange zest, orange juice, and vanilla. Whisk until combined.
    9. Sprinkle the flour, ginger, cinnamon, salt, and baking powder over the wet mixture, then stir to combine.
    10. Spread the batter into the prepared loaf pan and sprinkle the cinnamon-spiced fruit topping across the top.
    11. Bake for 25 to 30 minutes, or until a toothpick inserted into the center comes out clean. Move the pan from the oven to a cooling rack.
    12. Immediately add the meringue pieces across the top, if using. Press each one into the warm cake so it is secure. Cool in the pan for 10 minutes, then remove the cake from the pan.
    13. Allow to cool to room temperature before decorating with drizzles of icing (recipe follows), edible glitter, sanding sugar, or any other edible topping your heart desires.
    14. Slice into 8 pieces to serve.

    Notes

    How to make powdered sugar icing for drizzling: Whisk ½ cup powdered sugar with ½ to 2 teaspoons of milk until no lumps remain. If it’s too thick, add more liquid a few drops (about ½ teaspoon) at a time until it pours in a smooth ribbon. If it gets too runny, whisk in a pinch more powdered sugar.

    Nutrition

    • Serving Size: 1 slice
    • Calories: 310
    • Sugar: 27.3 g
    • Sodium: 45.7 mg
    • Fat: 11.1 g
    • Carbohydrates: 52.1 g
    • Protein: 3.5 g
    • Cholesterol: 69.1 mg

    Did you make this recipe?

    Tag @thismessisours on Instagram and hashtag it #thismessisours

    Recipe Card powered byTasty Recipes

    Frequently Asked Questions About Brown Butter, Answered

    Do you stir constantly when browning butter?

    Yes. Constant stirring keeps the milk solids moving so they toast evenly instead of burning on the bottom. It also lets you check the color underneath the foam. Continue stirring right up until the butter leaves the pan.

    How long does it take for butter to brown?

    Plan on 5 to 8 minutes over medium heat for the 6 tablespoons in this recipe. More butter takes longer. If you’re nervous, medium-low heat buys you extra time and control, at the cost of a few more minutes at the stove.

    Does brown butter have to be completely cooled before baking?

    Not completely, but it shouldn’t be hot. For this cake, let it cool while you soak the prunes and prep everything else, about 15 minutes. You want it warm, not steaming, so it doesn’t scramble the egg yolks. Recipes that call for creaming solid butter with sugar are different, since there you’ll need to chill the brown butter until it firms back up.

    Should I use salted or unsalted butter?

    Either one will brown. I use unsalted butter here because it lets me control the seasoning. If you have salted butter on hand, use it and cut the added salt in the batter roughly in half.

    What are some common mistakes when browning butter?

    The big ones are cranking the heat too high, using a dark pan, and walking away for “just a second.” Skipping the stirring is another, and so is leaving the finished butter in the pan, where carryover heat turns it into burnt butter fast. Last mistake: tossing those brown bits. Keep them. They’re the whole point.

    How do you store brown butter?

    Let it cool, then store brown butter in an airtight container in the fridge for about a week, or freeze it for a few months. It firms up as it chills. Bring it back to room temperature or warm it gently before you use it. A jar in the fridge is a gift to future you, whether you’re baking or spooning it over pasta and roasted squash for savory recipes.

    You May Also Like

    • Zoom out Cherry Dr Pepper cake.
      An Easy Homemade Cherry Dr Pepper Cake Recipe
    • London Fog cake
      A Recipe Inspired by a Latte: Blueberry London Fog Tea Cake
    • TMIO Marble Loaf-08
      A Better For You Chocolate and Vanilla Marble Loaf Cake
    « How to Make an Easy Lasagna Recipe That Is High in Protein

    Reader Interactions

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Recipe rating 5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

    Primary Sidebar

    EXCLUSIVE FROM GARDYN

    GET $100 OFF YOUR GARDYN ORDER - EXCLUSIVELY FROM THIS MESS IS OURS x GARDYN.

    USE PROMO CODE: THISMESSISOURS

     

    TRENDING

    • A table setting of plates and drinks with a sheet pan of freshly baked lasagna in the middle.How to Make an Easy Lasagna Recipe That Is High in Protein
    • TMIO frozen blueberries-4Step-By-Step How to Freeze Blueberries & Ways to…
    • Copy of Copy of Easy appetizerWhat to do in Ventura County, California - A Perfect Getaway
    • Blueberry Curd (12)How to Make a Creamy Homemade Blueberry Curd
    • A bowl of Cherry Brown Betty with vanilla ice cream.A Easy Cherry Brown Betty Recipe with California Prunes
    • A platter of Crispy Smashed Potatoes with Dirty Martini-Infused Olive Topping ready to serve.Crispy Smashed Potatoes with Dirty Martini-Infused…

    About Meg

    Life can get pretty complicated, especially around dinner time. Whether you’ve got picky eaters, or bonafide allergy concerns, we’ve got some inspiration that’ll get you excited to bring all of those wants, needs and like-to-have’s around your family table. I’ve put together a couple of quick articles and guides to help you get started on your journey, or maybe just to help you get to know us a little better. So dig in and see what we’re all about. Just don’t judge – because we’re a total mess! More About Us

    Footer

    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
    • YouTube

    Privacy Policy · Shop Policy

    Copyright © 2026 / This Mess Is Ours
    Lunch Monsters is a TM of This Mess Is Ours.

    This website uses cookies in order to provide you the best experience possible. Please accept cookies for optimal performance.